American restaurants

Hidden Valley Supper Club

4.5 198 reviews Closed 12704 County Rd M, Caroline, WI 54928, United States

Discover this place

If you’re seeking an authentic taste of Wisconsin's culinary charm, Hidden Valley Supper Club is the destination to savor. Nestled in the quaint town of Caroline, this American restaurant is renowned for a blend of hearty portions and friendly service that leave patrons raving. Customers consistently express delight over the deliciousness of the dishes, often citing the substantial servings for surprisingly low prices. Christine's first visit encapsulates the typical enthusiasm: "the food was absolutely delicious!"

With a focus on simple, comforting fare, the Friday fish buffet has garnered particular affection from locals like Michael, who cherishes the nostalgia of country roots. The culinary talent of John and Sara Knoll shines through in every dish, ensuring freshness and quality. Diners have commended options such as the three-piece walleye and delightful twice-baked potatoes, underscoring a commitment to homemade flavors rather than frozen alternatives. David's review sums it up perfectly: “If you are near here, don't miss it!”

For anyone in the area, Hidden Valley Supper Club is more than a meal; it’s a heartwarming experience that invites you to dine, connect, and relish the flavors of Wisconsin.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Brunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Hidden Valley Supper Club before visiting.

Reviews for Hidden Valley Supper Club

4.5

198 reviews

100%

36%

10%

Review highlights

Based on 198 reviews

Hidden Valley Supper Club is consistently praised for delivering a genuine American supper club experience characterized by generous portions, fresh and flavorful food, and affordable pricing. Reviewers commonly highlight the inviting, down-to-earth atmosphere and friendly, attentive service, which contribute to a welcoming dining environment. The menu emphasizes classic, hearty dishes—such as fish buffets and traditional holiday meals—prepared with care and authenticity. Customers appreciate the balance of quality and value, often noting the unexpected affordability given the sizeable servings and home-style preparation. Overall, Hidden Valley Supper Club stands out for its combination of excellent food, warm hospitality, and an unpretentious country charm that resonates with both locals and visitors alike.

Christine

Jun 24, 2025

It was my very first visit to a supper club and I definitely know now what all the fuss is about! The good was absolutely delicious! You get a huge quantity of food for a very low price. I definitely recommend!!!

Loah Horton

Jun 12, 2025

Food was delicious. People were friendly.perfect place to eat and enjoy yourself!

Michael Gutho

May 29, 2025

Simple, country, Friday fish buffet! One of my favorite places as a kid who was from the country but knows his roots today

Dale R. Schultz

Apr 18, 2025

The food is always fresh & tender. The price for a Thanksgiving dinner was 10 per plate & that included pie(s) for dessert. Not abed deal!! The cooks are: John & his wife Sara Knoll. Bring friends. It is located in Caroline, Wit., just north of Marino, Wit. on Hwy. G. Enjoy.

David Farrell

Mar 20, 2025

This place is perfect! Authentic supper club experience. The food is great and portions are gigantic! Everyone is friendly, and the service was delightful. Walleye had 3 large pieces and the twice baked is real, not from a freezer. Best part, the prices were a pleasant surprise. We expected our bill to be twice as high as it was. If you are near here, don't miss it!

Amy Allcox

Mar 12, 2025

Tracy is the best bartender! Ask for a tall, so she knows I sent you ;) Salad bar has everything you need! Buffet for 15 packed with goodness!!!

Bryan Bassett

Mar 07, 2025

Great food. I was very impressed with the friendly staff and home town feel of the guest experience.

Carl Thompson

Mar 07, 2025

No judgement here. All are welcome. Although it doesn't have the customary relish tray of a typical Wisconsin supper club it has all the other boxes checked. A shrine to a local baseball team, an electric organ, and a loins club membership. It's got a good variety of menu options. I might skip the lobster though. Sundrop in a bottle is always 5 stars